USMCA is ‘pennies and nickels’ for U.S. dairy farmers, says analyst

Mark Stephenson, director of dairy policy analysis, University of Wisconsin-Madison.

Increased access to the Canadian dairy market through the newly minted United States Mexico Canada Agreement (USMCA) will not be a boon for U.S. dairy farmers.

That’s the early verdict from Mark Stephenson, director of dairy policy analysis at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. “I think the dairy producers are not going to look at their milk cheques and see dollars as a result of this… it’s more like pennies and nickels along the way. It’s a fairly small impact on milk prices here in the U.S.”

The new trade pact concedes an additional 3.59 per cent market access to the U.S. and eliminates Canada’s milk pricing Classes 6 and 7.

Stephenson concurs with the National Milk Producers Association, which described the deal as “incremental progress” for U.S. producers. In an interview this week at the World Dairy Expo at Madison, Wisconsin, Stephenson noted he was not surprised to see the end of Class 6 and 7. “That was considered fairly toxic down here,” he says. (story continues below…)

Stephenson says there are many details to work through to get a full picture of the new deal but he believes mechanisms will likely remain for the Canadian industry to effectively price milk protein products. “I think that will mean that milk protein isolate that had been coming up into Canada is not going to be all that attractive to be sending up any longer, so it accomplishes the same thing that the Class 6 and 7 did,” he says. “What it probably does do is cap the amount of product that can be priced under the former Class 6 and 7 and sold on to world markets – skim milk powder, for example.”

In the interview (above), Stephenson discusses USMCA and the tremendous need for export markets to sell a flood of U.S. milk production. However, he does not believe the Canadian market is the answer to U.S. dairy troubles.

“I don’t think we’re looking at a tsunami of milk coming up into Canada from Wisconsin or New York. It will me more like a dribble that will be coming up in the way of product sales,” adds Stephenson.


Bernard Tobin

Bernard Tobin is Real Agriculture's Ontario Field Editor. AgBern was raised on a dairy farm near St. John's, Newfoundland. For the past two decades, he has specialized in agricultural communications. A Ryerson University journalism grad, he kicked off his career with a seven-year stint as Managing Editor and Field Editor for Farm and Country magazine. He has received six Canadian Farm Writers' Federation awards for journalism excellence. He's also worked for two of Canada's leading agricultural communications firms, providing public relations, branding and strategic marketing. Bern also works for Guelph-based Synthesis Agri-Food Network and talks the Real Dirt on Farming.


RealAg Radio, Dec. 10: May’s Monday market madness and latest drought monitor update

What a Monday in the markets as British Prime Minister, Theresa May, drops a bombshell statement in the House of Commons postponing Parliament's vote on Brexit. The uncertainty rocked the markets along with the news that the bail hearing for Huawei's CFO should be concluded by the end of the day. In news with Guse,…Read more »


Leave a Reply


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.