Three key issues Minister Bibeau needs to focus on first in 2021

Opinion

As we drift into a new year, an opportunity presents itself to refocus and take a fresh look at the issues at hand. Some people make New Year’s resolutions, some think about changes, and others take advantage of the fresh calendar to implement real change to benefit stakeholders and their own position. This restart with intent is true on farms, within the ag industry, and (perhaps) even government.

The Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food, Marie-Claude Bibeau, has several items already on the docket for this early part of 2021. Although these issues are important to farmers and ranchers, questions remain on how high a priority they are for the Liberal cabinet and the Prime Minister’s Office.

Fish or cut bait on BRM reform resolution

Reforming farm assistance programs took much of the agricultural lobbying oxygen in 2020 and there is little to show for the effort. Last year finished off with a stalemate between the Prairie provinces and the federal government on Bibeau’s proposed changes on the final day of the federal-provincial-territorial meeting. There was hope that a compromise could be found by Christmas or year’s end to allow for retroactive changes to AgriStability for 2020. That is now shrouded in doubt, as no agreement was reached. With the announcement of the climate and environmental plan in December, increased commodity prices, and pure topic exhaustion, Bibeau should either find compromise in early Q1 or cut bait and focus on the reformation of the risk management suite for the next five-year framework in 2023.  There will be bigger topics in 2021 to tackle…..

Address possible carbon tax exemptions for agriculture

The agricultural lobby was not successful in arguing for exemptions to the carbon tax for grain drying and heating at $20 and $30 per tonne in 2020, but the Liberals planning to raise the tax to $170 per tonne by 2030, the costs on agriculture could cross a threshold putting the argument for exemptions back in agriculture’s favour. Just switching to electricity is not a solution for many applications in agriculture, so the policy is widely viewed as a tax with little alternative options. Whether it be diesel-powered tractors or natural gas/propane grain dryers, farmers are challenged to find alternative fuels for many applications. This increase in cost to farmers is not balanced with recognizing the work farmers have done to sequester carbon through agronomic practices.

In June, the minister stated that the carbon tax on fuel for grain drying resulted in “insignificant costs” to farmers, a statement she may not be able to stick to with her government’s proposed carbon tax increases.

Agriculture’s role in the climate plan

Although the carbon tax gets most of the attention from the federal government’s climate plan there are other components that will touch agriculture. Both the Clean Fuel Standard (CFS) and new targets for reducing synthetic fertilizer use will impact agriculture. With the CFS finally reaching the Canada Gazette on the last possible week of December, farm groups will be working hard to understand the land use requirements in the first quarter while the minister will need to win over certain farm groups and farmers on the opportunity that this may be for grain and oilseed demand. Farmers in Canada do not appear to be as stalwart biofuel supporters as they are in the U.S. so Bibeau may have to be more granular on the possible benefits to farmers and how it fits into the climate plan. The other requirement in the climate plan is the 30% reduction target in synthetic fertilizer use that will need to be further flushed out by Minister Bibeau and stakeholders, including Fertilizer Canada, who initially showed a positive response to the new targets.

Honourable mentions

  • The COVID-19 vaccine roll out into agricultural sector. It’s critical that high risk workers in the food system are deemed a priority for getting the vaccine.  There has been lobbying by the worker unions and agriculture industry to see meat workers and certain farm workers get the vaccine as soon is deemed possible behind front line health care workers and the elderly.
  • Developing a good relationship with incoming USDA secretary Tom Vilsack. Previous combos of Bibeau/Perdue and MacAulay/Perdue were relatively solid and did not cause any harm to the important Canada/U.S. trade relationship
  • Sorting out the USTR challenge of Canada’s implementation of dairy TRQs under the new USMCA (CUSMA) agreement. Although this is more of a file for the trade minister, Vilsack knows the file well and Bibeau represents a dairy riding.

The Reality….

Minister Bibeau must re-establish trust with farmers in 2021 if she is going to be effective in this portfolio. A good example of the distrust were the changes to the CFS land use requirements. It appears that farm groups got many or most of what they asked for in the changes to the initial draft, yet farmers are having a hard time getting behind the CFS and there’s an assumption it will have a negative impact, largely based on the Liberals’ track record. When Minister Bibeau does deliver on an agricultural lobby ask, the Ministry has to find a way to get stakeholder credit or the PMO will see little need to deliver wins in the future without any possible political points.

Minister Bibeau is truly trapped in a position of being pushed by her portfolio stakeholders for changes that many times run perpendicular to the direction of her cabinet colleagues and the Prime Minister’s Office. All of this presents a very intriguing 2021 — as if 2020 wasn’t interesting enough.

One thought on “Three key issues Minister Bibeau needs to focus on first in 2021

  1. If we have increases as indicated of $170 per ton on the carbon tax and no other country is doing the same we will be seriously
    Disadvantaged, every unit of nitrogen fertilizer every product we buy, every load of grain being transported, there is a word I hate sustainability
    What has been talked about in this article carbon tax and limiting fertilizer use are definitely pressure which will be unsustainable to agriculture
    This government is about “looking” under mining moral standards they have not the intelligence to run there own house hold budgets let alone
    The finances of a country.
    We have to acknowledge change is need in how energy is produced, invest in technology that develops new power units to put in tractors and
    Combines or develop exhaust technology that removes all harmful pollutants, taxing the industries Ag included will kill the economy put people
    Out of work and cause recession, the current government needs to wake up or move out let people with real vision for build business and improving people’s lives not tax everyone food and homes

Leave a Reply

 

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Privacy Preference Center

Necessary

Necessary cookies help make a website usable by enabling basic functions like page navigation and access to secure areas of the website. The website cannot function properly without these cookies.

gdpr, __cfduid, PHPSESSID, wordpress_test_cookie, woocommerce_items_in_cart, woocommerce_cart_hash, wp_woocommerce_session, wordpress_logged_in, wordpress_sec, wp-settings, wp-settings-time, __cf_mob_redir, wordpress_cache, realag
__cfduid

Marketing

Measuring interactions with the ads on the domain.

__gads,fsk_ut_2317
IDE

Statistics

These are used to track user interaction and detect potential problems. These help us improve our services by providing analytical data on how users use this site.

_ga,_gid,_gat,_cb,_chartbeat2,_chartbeat4
_ga,_gid
metrics_token

Preferences

Preference cookies enable the website to remember information that changes the way the website behaves or looks, like your preferred language or the region that you are in.

chartdefaults, comment_author, comment_author_email, comment_author_url
JSESSIONID, _os_session,anonymous_votes,csrf-param,csrf-token,user,user-id,user-platform,intercom-session,intercom-lou,intercom-session
personalization_id, tfw_exp

 

Register for a RealAgriculture account to manage your Shortcut menu instead of the default.

Register