Canadian farmer sentiment plummets, as optimism for the coming year sours


In the January 2024 edition of the RealAgristudies Canadian Farmer Sentiment Index, the mood among Canada’s farmers and ranchers has notably darkened, with an increased level of concern about their financial health and the overall state of the Canadian agricultural economy.

This summary, drawing from the valuable insights of those who participated in the survey, highlights some critical findings and emerging trends:

  • Overall Sentiment: There’s a significant downturn in optimism, with farmers expressing a more negative outlook on both their immediate financial situations and the broader Canadian ag economy. This sentiment echoes the concerns and conversations I have had while giving keynote speeches the past two weeks, indicating a deep-rooted apprehension about 2024.
  • Current Financial Performance: Demonstrating a concerning trend, the Index shows a sharp decline from a positive score in January 2023 (119 out of 200) to a disheartening 86 out of 200 by January 2024, crossing below the neutral threshold of 100 and signalling increased pessimism.
  • Future Financial Performance: Contrary to the steep decline in current financial health, future financial performance expectations have shown a steadier, albeit slight, upward trend over the last 18 months. However, January 2024’s data reveals a convergence of current and future sentiments, both edging downward in a worrying shift.
  • Agricultural economy in the next 12 to 60 months: When we asked farmers whether there will be widespread good times or bad times in both time periods, farmers stated very clearly their pessimistic concerns.  In the open ended responses, federal government policies and specifically the carbon tax, were mentioned the most often as a reason.
  • Confidence in Marketing Crops: Confidence in marketing crops has emerged as a significant concern. The volatility of commodity markets is directly impacting this confidence, with price swings making it increasingly challenging for farmers to plan and secure profits. This is in line with what many analysts have been telling us in interviews in the fact many farmers are undersold as the market has slid to the downside in the past six to nine months.  With 75% of farmers telling us that they view 2024 as riskier than 2023, lack of confidence in marketing the crop is concerning.

The January 2024 Canadian Farmer Sentiment Index thus sheds light on the growing apprehensions within the agricultural community, underscoring the need for strategies to navigate the volatile commodity markets and bolster marketing confidence. Amid these challenges, the agricultural sector’s resilience is being tested, highlighting the importance of support and innovative solutions to weather the current uncertainties.

In the coming weeks we will be publishing data that dives deeper into these numbers to tell the story of farmer perceptions and sentiment as we edge closer to spring.

If you have any questions or comments please email [email protected].

Wake up with RealAgriculture

Subscribe to our daily newsletters to keep you up-to-date with our latest coverage every morning.

Wake up with RealAgriculture

Please register to read and comment.


Register for a RealAgriculture account to manage your Shortcut menu instead of the default.